Telephone Answering Service: Human vs AI Receptionist

Telephone answering service: the short answer

A telephone answering service picks up your business phone line when you can't, greets callers in your business name, takes the message or booking, and sends you the details straight away. In Australia you have two real choices today: a human telephone answering service, where trained receptionists in a call centre answer your diverted calls, or an AI receptionist, where conversational AI answers the line instantly, any hour.

Neither is automatically better. Humans handle emotion and odd requests well but are priced per call or per minute and often limited to business hours. AI answers every call at once, 24/7, for a flat monthly fee, but needs a clear knowledge base and a human to hand off to for the tricky ones. This guide focuses on the phone-line side: how your number actually gets to the service, what it costs, what hours you get, and when each option fits.

Miyai is an Australian AI receptionist. The AI voice receptionist on the Growth plan starts at $199 AUD/month, and website chat starts at $19 AUD/month, both paid through Stripe before access. See pricing or Get started.

How a telephone answering service connects to your phone line

Whichever service you pick, it only works if calls reach it. Most Australian businesses keep their existing number and use call diversion (call forwarding) so the service answers instead of voicemail. You choose when calls divert:

Divert typeWhen it kicks inCommon use
Divert all callsEvery call goes straight to the serviceSole traders on the tools, after-hours mode
Divert on no answerAfter your phone rings for a set number of secondsYou answer first, the service catches what you miss
Divert on busyWhen you're already on a callSecond callers aren't sent to voicemail
Divert when unreachablePhone off or no signalJob sites, flights, rural areas

On most Australian mobile networks these are set with standard GSM codes dialled from the handset, for example \*\*21\*number# (all calls), \*\*61\*number# (no answer), \*\*67\*number# (busy) and \*\*62\*number# (unreachable), and ##002# cancels all diverts. Landlines, NBN voice services, 1300/13 numbers and cloud phone systems set diversion in the provider's portal or app instead. Check two things with your carrier before you go live:

Then ring your own number from another phone and test each divert. It takes five minutes and catches most set-up problems.

Human telephone answering service: how it works

With a traditional telephone answering service, your diverted call lands with a receptionist in a shared call centre. They see your business name and script on screen, answer as if they work for you, take a message, sometimes book into your calendar or transfer the call, and send you the details by SMS or email.

Where humans are strong

Where humans struggle

If you want the full picture of operator-led services, including scripts and what to ask a provider about where calls are answered, read our guide to the live answering service. This post stays on the telephone side: connection, cost and hours.

AI receptionist: how it works on a phone line

An AI receptionist answers the same diverted line, but with conversational AI instead of a person. It picks up on the first ring, answers questions from your knowledge base (services, areas, hours, pricing guidance), captures the caller's name, number and job details, books appointments if you allow it, and sends a summary to your phone or CRM. If a caller needs a human, it can transfer the call or flag an urgent callback.

Where AI is strong

Where AI struggles

For a deeper walk-through of call flow, set-up and limitations, see our AI phone answering service in Australia guide.

Cost: per-call pricing vs flat monthly fees

Pricing models differ more than headline prices do, so compare them on your own call volume.

Human telephone answering services in Australia usually charge in one of these ways:

Prices vary widely by provider and inclusions, so get a written quote that spells out the per-call or per-minute overage rate and what happens in a busy month. A quiet month can look cheap; a month with a burst of storm-damage calls or a marketing campaign can cost several times more.

An AI receptionist is normally a flat monthly subscription. Miyai's Growth voice plan starts at $199 AUD/month, paid through Stripe before access; see pricing for what's included at each level. The useful comparison is your realistic monthly call count multiplied by the human service's per-call or per-minute rate, plus any after-hours fee, versus the flat AI fee.

Also count the cost of not answering. Our post on the cost of missing business calls shows how to estimate what each unanswered call is worth to you.

Hours: business hours, after hours and public holidays

Hours are where the two options differ most on a telephone line.

When each one fits

Choose a human telephone answering service if:

Choose an AI receptionist if:

Choose a hybrid if:

Many Australian service businesses land on the hybrid. Tradies, clinics, real estate offices and law firms use AI for first response and keep a human for escalation. Industry examples are in our posts for contractors and allied health.

Questions to ask any telephone answering service before you divert your line

  1. What happens when several of my calls come in at once?
  2. Exactly what hours are covered, and what does after-hours or public holiday cover cost?
  3. What's the per-call or per-minute overage rate, and how is a "call" counted?
  4. How do messages reach me: SMS, email, app or CRM? How fast?
  5. Can calls be transferred to me live, and on what rules?
  6. Where are calls answered and where is call data stored? (Our data security post explains why this matters.)
  7. What's the minimum contract, and how do I cancel and take my diverts back?

Frequently asked questions

What is a telephone answering service? It's a service that answers your business phone line when you can't, using your business name, and passes on messages, bookings or transfers. It can be run by human receptionists or by an AI receptionist.

Do I need a new phone number? Usually not. You keep your number and set call diversion to the service, either for all calls or only on busy, no answer or unreachable.

Is an AI receptionist cheaper than a human answering service? Often, once call volume or after-hours cover goes up, because AI is a flat monthly fee while human services usually charge per call or minute. Compare quotes against your real call numbers.

Can an AI telephone answering service transfer calls to me? Yes. Miyai can transfer callers or flag urgent callbacks based on rules you set, so a person still handles the calls that need one.

Does a telephone answering service work with 1300 numbers? Yes. Set the diversion or answer point in your 1300 provider's portal so calls reach the service.

Next step

If your phone line still goes to voicemail when you're busy or after hours, start with one divert, test it, and see how many calls you've been missing. Compare plans on pricing or Get started. Growth voice starts at $199 AUD/month and chat at $19 AUD/month, paid through Stripe before access.

Back to the Miyai AI blog